DOJ Urges Judge to Overturn Ruling in Nursing Home Case

DOJ Urges Judge to Overturn Ruling in Nursing Home Case


The United States Department of Justice has asked a federal judge to reverse a verdict siding with Consulate Health Care and throwing out a $348 million lawsuit against the company.  Consulate was accused by whistleblowers of overcharging Medicare and Medicaid by artificially increasing therapy times, but in January a judge threw out the case for insufficient evidence.

However, the DOJ is now calling on the judge to overturn that ruling and allow the case to be retried.  The DOJ accused the judge of committing errors in the case that hamper the government’s ability to pursue fraud cases.

Whistleblower Angela Ruckh, a former Consulate employee, appealed United States District Judge Steven Merryday’s verdict.  Ruckh originally pursued the case, and she would stand to make $50 million for coming forward and whistleblowing.

Consulate Health Care is the nation’s sixth largest provider of nursing homes, primarily operating on the East Coast. The lawsuit alleges massive government fraud committed by the nursing home group in which Consulate falsified therapy time in order to receive more Medicare and Medicaid money.  Consulate denies these charges and continues to operate their homes.

The case is somewhat of a rarity as Ruckh, a registered nurse, filed the lawsuit after the federal and state governments failed to intervene in the case of the fraud.  District Judge Merryday threw out the case in part due to federal and state governments failing to catch Consulate’s fraud.

But, now as the DOJ has entered the arena, Merryday may face pressure to overturn his ruling as the federal government has expressed concern with the nursing home fraud.  Some argue that throwing out the case was too broad of an interpretation of Escobar, a 2016 Supreme Court ruling.


Consulate Health Care nursing home residents will be left in somewhat of a limbo as the case lingers on.  The group remains under a watchful from the government, but if the group is made to fork over their fraudulently earned money, the future of these nursing homes will be in question.

We can Help! Our local advisors can help your family make a confident decision about senior living.

Call: 800-997-1342


Alec Pronk
Alec Pronk

Political writer who also enjoys playing and watching soccer, basketball and chess. I also enjoy teaching English as a Foreign Language among other subjects.

All comments will go into moderation and they will need to be approved by an administrator before appearing on the blog

All copyrights reserved © 2018 • Design and Development Boomers Assistance Facilities